Love at First Bite: Brownie Sundae for Two with Breyers Ice Cream

Picture this: warm, fudgy brownies fresh out of the oven, topped with the smooth, velvety embrace of Breyers ice cream, and shared with someone who makes your heart melt. It’s not just dessert—it’s a love story served on a plate.

Whether you're celebrating an anniversary, surprising your sweetheart with a spontaneous date night, or simply cozying up at home, this brownie ice cream sundae for two is the ultimate way to scoop up sweet memories together. So, grab an apron, a dollop of love, and your favorite Breyers ice cream flavor—let’s whip up something truly irresistible.

Why a Brownie Sundae is the Perfect Pairing for Two

This dessert is perfect to share because it combines warmth, comfort, and indulgence in every bite. Whether it’s for a Valentine’s Day celebration (or Galentines!), an anniversary, or just a cozy evening at home, there’s something special about enjoying a treat together. The rich, gooey brownies paired with cold, creamy ice cream create a harmony of textures that’s as delightful as it is decadent. Best of all, this simple yet luxurious recipe makes it easy to serve a dessert that feels as special as the moment you’re celebrating.

What Your Favorite Ice Cream Flavor Says About You

Now, let’s talk about the star of the show: ice cream. With so many rich, creamy flavors to choose from, there’s a Breyers flavor that perfectly suits you and your loved one. Here’s a playful take on what your ice cream pick says about you:

chocolate ice cream and brownies in a clear glass

Chocolate: The classic romantic

If chocolate is your love language, Breyers' Extra Creamy Chocolate is the perfect partner to warm, gooey brownies. The double dose of chocolatey bliss creates a decadent, melt-in-your-mouth experience that’s hard to beat.

Mint chocolate chip: The adventurer

For couples who love to add a little zest to their lives, Breyers Mint Chocolate Chip is a fresh and fun choice. The cool mint and crunchy cookie pieces add a refreshing and exciting element to the warm, gooey brownies, making each bite a delightful surprise.

Vanilla: The timeless sweetheart

Sometimes, keeping it simple is the sweetest choice. And as the maker of the number one vanilla ice cream in America, we know how to do simple right. Breyers' Natural Vanilla ice cream delivers a velvety, smooth flavor that perfectly complements the rich, fudgy texture of brownies. This classic duo is a match made in dessert heaven, ideal for anyone who knows that the basics, when done right, are anything but boring. It's the ultimate scoop of comfort and nostalgia.

If you, or your partner, have specific dietary needs, don’t worry—love isn’t the only thing we cater to. Explore the CarbSmart, Gluten Free, Non-Dairy and No Sugar Added ranges, thoughtfully crafted so you can savor dessert together. Because every sweet moment deserves to be shared.

Discover more dessert ideas for a low carb lifestyle: Breyers CarbSmart Recipes

Your Guide to a Brownie Sundae Made for Two

Brownie sundae with ice cream and cherries on top

Now that you’ve chosen your perfect flavor, let’s get started on making this lavish chocolate brownie sundae recipe. It’s easy, indulgent, and oh-so-satisfying.

All you need is some brownie mix (or homemade recipe if you’re feeling extra), a tub of your favorite ice cream flavor and some delicious toppings (cherries and chocolate chips are classic romantic touches).

Find the full recipe here.

Ice cream brownie sundae in a mason jar with strawberries

Add gourmet toppings. Give it an extra crunch with some crushed cookies or granola.
Combine flavors. Why use only one ice cream flavor when you could use two? Find your perfect Breyers combo like French Vanilla and Dulce de Leche or Coffee and Pistachio Almond.
Try mixing in gelato. Add a scoop of gelato alongside your ice cream for a creamy, velvety texture. Pair Breyers Homemade Vanilla with Talenti Sea Salt Caramel or try Breyers REESE'S Chocolate with Talenti Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Gelato for a rich, indulgent duo that’s perfect for chocolate and peanut butter lovers.
Toss in some extra frozen treats. Take your sundae to the next level with cool, unexpected additions. Think outside the box with treats like Yasso Poppables (creamy frozen Greek yogurt bites dunked in a crunchy, chocolatey shell) or frozen fruit pieces like chocolate-dipped bananas or strawberries.
Perk up your presentation. Serve in mason jars for a cute, rustic presentation. For a more elegant touch, use glass dessert bowls or parfait glasses.

And there you have it—a brownie sundae recipe as sweet and simple as love itself. Perfect for sharing with your significant other or a loved one, this indulgent dessert transforms any moment into a celebration of togetherness. Whether you’re toasting an anniversary, marking a special occasion, or simply enjoying a well-deserved sweet escape, this sundae is the cherry on top of your romantic memories. So, grab your spoons, savor the love in every bite, and let the sweetness linger long after the last scoop!

Why stop here? Uncover endless dessert possibilities with our Ice Cream Sundae Recipes.

FAQs

Can I use store-bought brownies for this recipe?

Absolutely! Store-bought brownies work perfectly for this recipe. Just make sure to choose your favorite brand and you're good to go. It’s all about making things simple and delicious.

What are some other Breyers flavors I can use in this recipe?

You can really get creative with this brownie sundae recipe by trying different flavors each time. If you want to double down on the chocolate indulgence, try the REESE’S Chocolate frozen delight or if you want to spice up the classics, try Rocky Road, Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough or Chocolate Truffle.

How can I make this brownie sundae gluten-free?

To make this brownie sundae gluten-free, simply use gluten-free brownies. There are plenty of great gluten-free brownie mixes available at the store. Then, pair them with any of the Gluten Free Ice Cream flavors, like Vanilla Fudge Twirl or Butter Pecan, and you’re all set!

Can I make this recipe ahead of time?

Yes, you can bake the brownies and let them cool, then store them in an airtight container. When you’re ready to serve, simply add your favorite Breyers ice cream and toppings. This way, you can enjoy a quick and easy dessert whenever you like.

Are there any vegan options for this dessert?

Definitely! Breyers offers delicious Non-Dairy options that are perfect for a vegan brownie sundae. We like to pair vegan brownies with Non-Dairy Vanilla Peanut or Non-Dairy Cookies & Crème.

We can’t wait to see what you create! Share your brownie sundae creations with us @breyers on Instagram.

Cherry Vanilla

Coffee

Natural Strawberry

Continue

Adchoices - Do not sell or Share

© 2025 The Magnum Ice Cream Company . All rights reserved.

This web site is directed only to U.S. consumers for products and services of The Magnum Ice Cream Company United States.
This web site is not directed to consumers outside of the U.S.