Why Serve a No Sugar Added Dessert for Thanksgiving

These days, sugar-conscious eating isn’t just a trend; it’s part of how more families celebrate the holidays. Whether you’re hosting kids or just trying to be a little more mindful this year, having at least one low sugar option makes the dessert table way more inclusive.

After all, by the time dessert hits the Thanksgiving table, everyone’s already loaded up on stuffing, sides, and more carbs than anyone’s willing to admit. And while there’s always room for pie, not everyone wants (or can handle) another sugar bomb.

That’s where a little balance comes in. Breyers’ No Sugar Added Frozen Dairy Desserts range brings all the cozy dessert vibes, without the additional sugar overload.

5 No Sugar Added Frozen Thanksgiving Desserts Ideas You’ll Fall For

Get ready for a Thanksgiving feast that is sugar-conscious, but full of flavor. Below, we’ve listed five of our favorite crowd-pleasing Thanksgiving desserts.

Better For You Swaps: You can tailor these Thanksgiving dessert recipes to your dietary needs by swapping the classic flavors with one of our diet-friendly options, including CarbSmart™, Gluten Free, Lactose Free and Non-Dairy.

To keep these desserts lower in sugar, make a few simple substitutes:

Use our Better For You swaps or yogurts in place of regular ice cream
Sugar substitutes like stevia, monk fruit, or allulose instead of granulated or brown sugar
Sugar-free cookies or graham crackers for crusts
Unsweetened canned pumpkin, applesauce, or fruit purées can add natural sweetness without the extra sugar
And don’t forget — spices like cinnamon, nutmeg, and vanilla extract boost flavor so you won’t miss the sugar!

1. Pumpkin Ice Cream Pie

Pumpkin spice meets cozy comfort in this creamy pie. Instead of baking, it starts with a layer of ice cream (swap Homemade Vanilla for No Sugar Added Vanilla), mixed with real pumpkin purée and warm fall spices, all nestled into a graham cracker or almond flour crust.

Once frozen, it slices like a dream and feels as creamy and spiced as your favorite fall drink.

Get the recipe: Pumpkin Ice Cream Pie

2. Sweet Potato Ice Cream Pie

Think roasted sweet potatoes, blended smooth and folded into creamy vanilla ice cream (replace Natural Vanilla in this recipe for No Sugar Added Vanilla). It’s poured into a nutty crust, frozen until firm, and served with a sprinkle of cinnamon or a dollop of whipped topping.

This frozen dessert for Thanksgiving is sweet, warmly spiced and feels like a homemade favorite, even though it takes just minutes to make.

Get the recipe: Sweet Potato Ice Cream Pie

Thanksgiving Gingersnap Ice Cream Squares

3. Gingersnap Ice Cream Squares

These frosty little squares taste like the holidays in every bite. They’ve got layers of cinnamon-spiked gingersnap cookies softened by scoops of ice cream. This recipe calls for Natural Vanilla, but try CarbSmart™ Vanilla, instead. Then, they’re frozen into perfectly sliceable bars. The snappy texture of the gingersnaps adds a cozy crunch that contrasts beautifully with the creamy topping.

Serve them straight from the freezer with a crumble of toasted pecans or a drizzle of sugar-free caramel sauce for a dessert that feels like grandma’s cookie tin.

Get the recipe: Gingersnap Ice Cream Squares

4. Oh My Apple Pie

Picture warm, cinnamon-spiced apples layered into a dish with cold scoops of Breyers No Sugar Added Vanilla and crushed pecan nuts (in place of Butter Pecan). Pieces of crushed golden pie crust add that satisfying crunch and makes this dessert feel like your favorite apple pie, only easier and ready in minutes.

Get the recipe: Oh My! Apple Pie

Thanksgiving Turkey Ice Cream Cake made with Breyers Vanilla Ice Cream

5. Turkey Ice Cream Cake

This cheeky showstopper swaps the traditional turkey for layers of Breyers Homemade Vanilla, peanut butter, frosted whipped topping, chocolate-covered pretzels and a turkey-shaped decoration on top. Want to swap out the candy? Try unsweetened coconut flakes, sugar-free chocolate shavings, toasted nuts, or even fresh berries for a pop of color. If you still want a playful “turkey look,” use fruit slices (like strawberry or apple fans) or low-sugar pretzels to create the feathers. It’s glossy, goofy, and guaranteed to steal the spotlight (no gravy required).

Get the recipe: Turkey Ice Cream Cake

How to Make Sure Everyone Enjoys Dessert This Thanksgiving

Making your Thanksgiving dessert table more balanced doesn’t mean changing your entire menu. Here are a few thoughtful tricks to make this day sweeter for everyone:

Mini portions go a long way: Let guests sample multiple desserts without overload.
Keep it inclusive: Cater your desserts to have a low sugar or low carb option and at least one dairy-free treat. This way you’ll ensure everyone has something to enjoy.
Label everything: Cute cards with tags like “No Sugar Added” or “Low Carb” make it easy for guests to choose confidently.

FAQs

Is Breyers No Sugar Added Ice Cream good for diabetics?

As always, we recommend checking with your healthcare provider to ensure our products fit into your specific dietary needs

How do I serve low-sugar options without making them feel like an afterthought?

Make your low-sugar desserts look and taste just as good as the traditional ones! Use toppings, garnishes, and fun serving ideas, and no one will feel like they’re missing out.

A 48 ounce tub of Breyers® Non-Dairy Cookies & Creme simple pack image packshot

Non-Dairy Cookies & Crème

A 48 ounce tub of Breyers® CarbSmart™ Mint Cookie Fudge simple pack image packshot

CarbSmart™ Mint Fudge Cookie

REESE'S Peanut Butter

slide 1
slide 2
slide 3

Continue

Adchoices - Do not sell or Share

© 2025 The Magnum Ice Cream Company . All rights reserved.

This web site is directed only to U.S. consumers for products and services of The Magnum Ice Cream Company United States.
This web site is not directed to consumers outside of the U.S.