Scoop of Breyers Butter Pecan on green background

Is Butter Pecan the Ultimate Flavor for Creamy Dessert Sandwiches?

If you’ve ever tasted Breyers’ Butter Pecan frozen dairy dessert, you know it’s a flavor that stands the test of time. There’s something about the buttery, toasted pecans swirled into sweet, velvety vanilla that brings back memories of summer afternoons, homemade desserts, and sneaking an extra spoonful straight from the carton.

At the same time, ice cream sandwiches have long been a go-to treat for backyard barbecues, spring picnics and lazy Sunday afternoons. With its nostalgic appeal and perfect balance of sweet and salty, it’s no surprise that Butter Pecan is the perfect choice for these sweet dessert sandwiches.

So, what’s the scoop behind this timeless classic? Let’s dig in.

What Makes Butter Pecan Desserts So Good?

At the heart of Breyers Butter Pecan is a blend of rich, buttery vanilla and perfectly roasted pecans. The pecans are roasted in butter to bring out their natural warmth and nuttiness, then mixed into our creamy, indulgent vanilla base for the perfect balance of sweetness and crunch.

And you can rest assured that we choose our ingredients with care. We partner with American farmers to source 100% Grade A milk and cream from cows not treated with artificial growth hormones. We also work with the Rainforest Alliance and other organizations to ensure that every bit of vanilla is sustainably sourced.

That fine balance of crunch and creamy smoothness is what we think makes Butter Pecan a natural fit for dessert sandwiches. The right cookie can take the experience to another level—crisp butter cookies enhance the caramel notes, chewy oatmeal cookies give you a softer texture, and classic chocolate chip cookies create the perfect salty-sweet contrast.

With a flavor this timeless and versatile, Butter Pecan is a serious contender for the best cookie sandwich filling. If you haven’t tried it yet, here are some delicious ideas to get you started.

Homemade Butter Pecan Sandwich Recipes

Let’s start with the basics. Every good cookie sandwich starts with the right foundation. That is, you need to choose the perfect "bread" for your sandwich.

Pick your favorite and get ready to assemble a next-level treat:

Oat Cookie Sandwich

If you love a soft, chewy bite, oat cookies are the way to go. Their texture pairs beautifully with our creamy Butter Pecan flavor, while the oats enhance the nutty, toasty notes. A hint of cinnamon or brown sugar in the cookie deepens the warmth and brings out the buttery richness of the frozen dessert.

Try it: Swap vanilla ice cream for Butter Pecan in this recipe – Oat Cookie Ice Cream Sandwiches Recipe

Graham cracker ice cream sandwiches with ice cream filling on a tray plate

Graham Cracker Sandwich

For a crisp, lightly sweet contrast, graham crackers are a perfect match. Their subtle honey and spice notes complement the buttery vanilla base without overpowering it.

Try it: Switch vanilla ice cream for Butter Pecan in this recipe – Homemade Graham Cracker Ice Cream Sandwiches

Stack of delicious waffle ice cream sandwiches.

Waffle Sandwich

If you’re in the mood for something extra indulgent, waffles are the answer. Lightly toasted, they offer the perfect mix of crisp edges and a soft, airy center. Their buttery flavor naturally blends with Butter Pecan, and the pockets help hold everything in place. A Belgian waffle with a touch of maple or vanilla? Next level.

Try it: Simply replace vanilla ice cream with Butter Pecan in this recipe – Waffle Ice Cream Sandwiches

Tips to Enjoy Butter Pecan Cookie Sandwiches

Switch Up Your Cookies

Classic options like graham crackers or sugar cookies are always a safe bet, but why not get creative? Shortbread’s crumbly texture makes for an ultra-smooth ice cream sandwich that practically melts in your mouth. For a more indulgent option, pair Butter Pecan with gooey chocolate chip cookies.

Make It a Party

Ice cream sandwiches are even better when shared, so why not turn them into a fun dessert spread? Dip your homemade sandwiches in melted chocolate for an extra layer of indulgence, then top them with sprinkles. Serve alongside mini waffle cone “teacups” for a whimsical afternoon treat. Get the full recipe here.

If you have dietary needs, don’t worry—you can still enjoy delicious dessert sandwiches. Breyers offers a range of diet-friendly options, including Breyers CarbSmart™, No Sugar Added, Gluten-Free, and Non-Dairy varieties. While Butter Pecan is only available in the classic range, you’re sure to find a flavor you love in our Better For You collection.

More Butter Pecan Desserts to Try

Butter Pecan isn't just for sandwiches. You can use this delicious flavor to add a buttery twist to many sweet creations.

Creamy Butter Pecan Frozen Milkshake next to a tub of Breyers Butter Pecan.

Butter Pecan Milkshake

Turn your favorite flavor into a decadent drinkable treat. Simply blend Breyers Butter Pecan with a splash of milk, maple syrup and some cinnamon for the ultimate creamy delight. Get the full recipe here.

Cup of Apple pie-inspired dessert with butter pecan frozen dessert

Oh My! It’s Apple Pie

Why choose between pecan pie and apple pie when you can have both? Our Oh My, It’s Apple Pie recipe gives you the best of both worlds, combining tart, crunchy apples, and indulgent butter pecan. Get the full recipe here.

You could also try butter pecan cookies, as well as tortoni and sundae cups. It's also the perfect choice for our rolled ice cream recipe.

In a Nutshell

Butter pecan cookie sandwiches are a top-tier frozen treat, combining rich, nutty flavors with creamy sweetness. Whether you’re keeping it simple with classic cookies or going all out with a fun dessert spread, there’s no wrong way to enjoy this indulgent treat.

FAQs

What makes Butter Pecan different from other flavors?

Our Butter Pecan frozen dessert is a classic that stands out with its rich, buttery flavor and the crunchy roasted pecan texture. It offers a perfect balance of creamy sweetness and nutty goodness that’s both comforting and indulgent.

What cookies are best for butter pecan sandwiches?

When it comes to choosing the best cookies for your dessert sandwiches, think of flavors that complement the buttery, nutty profile of butter pecan. Classic choices like oatmeal cookies or snickerdoodles add a cozy touch, while shortbread cookies enhance the buttery richness.

What are some fun ways to serve butter pecan sandwiches?

Butter pecan sandwiches are such versatile treats. You can turn them into an indulgent cake, make mini versions for your ice cream tea party, or make them the star of your DIY ice cream bar, complete with toppings and sauces. The possibilities are endless!

Where can I buy Breyers Butter Pecan?

You can find our delicious Butter Pecan flavor and all your favorite Breyers flavors at most major grocery stores across the country. Use our easy store locator tool to find your nearest retailer.

We’d love to see your creations! Share your butter pecan ice cream sandwiches with us @breyers on Instagram.

A 48 ounce tub of Breyers® Dulce de Leche front of pack packshot

slide 1
slide 2
slide 3

Continue